Hotels That Serve Up the Best Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys
A little sweet, a little tart, key lime pie is a creamy blending of simple ingredients that, when executed correctly, creates a barefootin’ dance party for your taste buds. Egg yolks, sweetened condensed milk, and the juice of key limes are all that is needed to create the filling, but from there, creativity can elevate it into the stratosphere or leave you longing for simplicity.
This popular Keys' dessert was created in Key West in the late 1800s, but it wasn't declared Florida's official state pie until 2006! Want to know where to get a tasty slice of paradise in the Florida Keys? Here’s our list of hotels that serve the best key lime pie from Key Largo to Key West.
Sunset Key Cottages
Why it made the list
As if we didn’t already love Latitudes restaurant for its romantic setting and Key West sunsets, their key lime pie is a true classic. Authentic in every way, from the abundant graham cracker crust to the soft yellow hue of the velvety filling (key lime pie must be soft yellow in color or it’s not key lime pie!). Fluffy peaks of sugary toasted merengue melt on your tongue.
Check Rates for Hotels
on the List
BACK TO TOP
