For a good quality bag at a reasonable price, I look for the Rick Steves name on it. http://www.luggageshowroom.com/rick-steves-lug_m7036.html?ppc=1737&af=1737&s_kwcid=rick%20steves%20luggage|18728854432&gclid=CKrA0ZTcs7MCFS6CQgodq3cA4g
I never had a rolling backpack but I use my Rick Steves backpack quite often.

Why a duffle? I've used an Eagle Creek convertible backpack, and currently am using a Rick Steves rolling 21 inch bag, both for extensive foreign travel, but I don't see the point of a duffle, especially one with wheels.

Blue, I would agree with Thursdaysd and suggest a convertible backpack rather than a wheeled duffel. I have one from eBags (MotherLode weekender convertible backpack). It is carryon size but can hold way more than it should be able to, plus it expands for extra space while traveling or if you want to check it. It's held up to my craziness so it's pretty sturdy!

They also have a wheeled duffel that is basically a cross between a standard roller bag and a duffel bag. That means it takes up about 1/2 the space of a standard roller bag and weighs less. (MotherLode TLS Mini Wheeled Duffel).

If you want to stay with wheels and no frame at all, do be careful as they often just seem to have wheels at the bottom of one side and they never hold up worth a dang. You said that the one you looked at doesn't stand up but flops over... that would drive me NUTS!

Do you know that the grad specifically *wants* a rolling duffel? If not, I would suggest the wheeled duffel as a bag that covers most bases.

Thanks for the suggestions. I primarily was looking for something they could pack a lot into - not necessarily for flying - although it would be nice to have something they can use for both. I'll check into the site!

Blueslipper, did you see all the responses to your first posting of this question?

If you aren't using it for flying, I'd reconsider the "rolling" feature. If this is for car or bus travel you really don't need frame/wheels and then the overall weight of the bag will be a lot less.

I respectively disagree with most of the above posters. We use a very large rolling duffle especially for our teenager. Even when traveling by car, you need to get the bag from the car to hotel, house etc. The one we have was about $30 and has lasted years, it is a no-name brand and we got it at a local discount store. You should look at places that specifally cater to sleep-away camp items. I think you can get one that is similar to ours for about $80.

I have a rolling 29 inch duffel I have used for years and I love it. I do check it, there is always room for one more thing!....and its very easy for this old out of shape grannie to handle.

Empty it weighs 8 lbs, which is much less than the empty 12 lb Ricardo suitcase i got rid of.

DUH....Forgot to answer the original question...... I bought my duffel at Ross for $40. Super return on my investment!