A major find for us two years ago was Anastasia State Park, in St. Augustine. It is glorious, and was empty in Early February. We stayed nearby just south on Route A1A I think it was, while visiting a friend who had winter job as a ranger at the park.

We dined in St. Augustine, which is a very interesting historic town, a bit touristy, but worth checking out. The park is a stunning place with superlative beach.

tracy, for years I went to a condo at Anastasia and I loved it. Quiet. Peaceful. Wide sand beach. Really liked the condo too. It would be perfect for your family. Fast forward years later and one of my reps was relocating and could live anywhere in north Florida. She chose the exact same condo complex (her husband was retired so they kept their home in S. Fl). I'll send you a link. There's no "town" but on nights we weren't cooking we'd go into St. Augustine or even down to Daytona Beach. Great place.

http://www.anastasiacondos.com/

In the original building the units are set back so all the units have some sort of view. All of the units have wall to wall, floor to ceiling windows with sliders to a small patio. In the 2br units, the 2nd bedroom is in the back of the unit, near the entrance door. There is an elevator and a small pool. Loved the place.

"I imagine renting bikes and biking to town for casual lunches and dinners, visiting some historic sites"

Jekyll Island would be perfect for that.

Thank you both for your replies! I'll definitely have to check out Anastasia State Park.

Jo (starrs), thank you for the link! And interesting you brought up Jekyll Island because we considering the Georgia coast as well. I almost posted a different question, asking for opinions as to whether to go to the Georgia Coast or northern Florida. I was kind of eying St. Simons, but I hadn't gotten too far into my research yet. My one concern with Georgia is that maybe the area is too sleepy? Is there enough to do to keep us entertained for a week? Granted the girls go down at 7:30 every night so it's not like we need any kind of nightlife. I would be interested in taking the ferries to some of the smaller uninhabited islands. If you don't mind, would you mind giving me a comparison between the two areas?

Decisions decisions!
Tracy

See, I like "sleepiness"

Jekyll is perfect for biking around the island.

But it sounds like this is a better fit for what you are looking for - http://www.pontevedra.com/

My SIL and her family have been going for years (grandparents take the two daughters and the grandkids). My best friend now goes with her sons and granddaughters. There's more going on there. I think that's more like what you are looking for. My BF s it there - and previous visits were to St. George Island on the gulf. They always rented a private house with pool. They were very happy with a house at PV and sharing the resort pool.

Jo, I like sleepiness too...just a little concerned about staying for an entire week. Most of the vacation rentals seem to come with one week minimums. Ideally we would try to spend 3 nights in Georgia and then 4 nights in northern Florida but the girls and hotel rooms don't really work together...for us or our poor neighbors trying to sleep next door! So a rental makes more sense. I'm on the Jekyll Island website right now trying to read more about it.

Ponte Vedra looks lovely! Is it only the resort? I don't mind staying on a resort necessarily but I definitely want to be able to eat and explore in nice small towns away from the resort.

Sorry if I'm being annoying! I'm not 100% sure what I'm looking for myself. Actually I am...I want the atmosphere of the Outer Banks (we stayed in Duck) but without having to go back to the Outer Banks!

"I am looking for laid-back beach towns that aren't super-touristy (no Myrtle Beach-types for us!) and I'm trying to figure out if the beaches around St. Augustine fit what we are looking for."

In addition to Anastasia State Park, let me add Crescent Beach. You can see the exact location here: http://beacherslodge.com/images/content/mapofstaugustine.pdf

It is family-friendly and features soft white sand and very small "crowds". It is definitely off the tourist trail. We have owned a condo here for 22+ years and find that it is the perfect getaway. St. Augustine is just 15-20 minutes north. Here are some links:

http://www.staugustine.com/visit/
http://www.visitflorida.com/St_Augustine
http://www.getaway4florida.com/


"I found some nice ones near Flagler Beach. Is this a nice town?"

Not nearly as nice as the St. Augustine area beaches.

__________________________________________________
Vic's travels: http://my.flightmemory.com/vogilvie

Vic, thank you for your reply! I have a few Crescent Beach condos (and a few Anastasia ones) bookmarked so I'm happy to know it's a nice area. Still trying to narrow down which one to stay. I'm really excited!

Tracy

I live in the area, have been to all above mentioned beaches, and have two small children (4 and 6). My first choice would be Amelia Island, FL. Second choice would be St. Augustine. I would not choose Jekyll.

Another Georgia mom here- I agree with Georgia Gal. Amelia would be my first choice. St. Augustine if I wanted more options for non-beach activities. No to Jekyll. Ponte Vedra is a lovely resort.