Welcome:
Login/Register

Chez Mathilde Review

Read our Aruba restaurant reviews. Or post your own.

Chez Mathilde

$$$-$$$$, French, Oranjestad

User Rating: **** 3.6

Fodor's Review:

Long considered an essential stop by serious food lovers, Chez Mathilde continues to provide modern French cuisine in the elegant surroundings of a 19th-century building. The formal dining area features burnished walls, antique lamps, and crisp white linens laid over magenta and cobalt silk skirtings. You'll almost expect Edith Piaf to walk in and burst into song. The garden room at the back provides a more relaxed, belle epoque feel, with high ceilings, potted palms, and wicker chairs. An imaginative spirit pervades the menu in offerings like duck breast and crusted ostrich breast served with asparagus and truffled potatoes. Presentation is top-notch, and you'll appreciate soothing touches like a palate-cleansing mango sherbet served between courses. Aproned waiters provide attentive but understated service. Leave room for the outstanding desserts, such as the heady Grand Marnier soufflé, and be sure your credit cards have room to spare. The restaurant -- run by descendants of the home's last inhabitant -- is a VIP member of the AGA.

Member Reviews & Ratings:

Memorable!!!

Posted by NYCfamily from New York on 8/16/08

It is not an easy challenge to match the quality of top NYC restaurants-- Chez Mathilde does it. We had a superb dinner yesterday; the gold chef-selection menu was excellently prepared and served. Service was attentive and impeccable. Were it in NYC, it would have likely win a Zagat rating of 25-26.
FOOD: 4.0
ATMOSPHERE: 5.0
SERVICE: 5.0
VALUE: 4.0
RATING: 4.4

Highly overrated

Posted by Carolsn from Norfolk, Virginia on 3/13/08

Pretty place, appetizer and crepes Suzette were wonderful. Toughest piece of Chateaubriand I've ever eaten. Disappointing, we canceled our 2nd reservation.
FOOD: 2.0
ATMOSPHERE: 4.0
SERVICE: 4.0
VALUE: 2.0
RATING: 2.8

 

INFO

  • Address: Havenstraat 23, Oranjestad
  • Phone: 297/583-4968
  • Web site
  • Keep in mind: Reservations essential.
  • Credit Cards: AE, D, DC, MC, V
  • Closed: No lunch Sun.

Travel Talk

Visit the Travel Talk forums for help on planning your trip