$, Cat Island
Fodor's Review:
Use this friendly, family-run motel and apartment property as a base for exploring the island on your own -- including the nearby beach. The wood-panel rooms have high ceilings, private baths, and cable TV. The snappy apartments have 2 bedrooms, 1 1/2 baths, cable TV, and full kitchens. The dining room (-$) serves tasty local fare for breakfast. They can pack you a picnic lunch, and there's fresh seafood for dinner, along with live entertainment most Friday and Saturday nights. Complimentary shuttle service is available from the New Bight airport.
Visit the Travel Talk forums for help on planning your trip