Shelter Island Hotels

Read our Shelter Island hotel reviews. Or post your own.

View All Hotels Hotels: Shelter Island(4 found)

Name	Price	Location

Bay Club Hotel & Marina Member Rating: 5.0 Map \| Rooms in this appealing low-rise Shelter Island property are large...	$$	Shelter Island

Humphrey's Half Moon Inn & Suites Member Rating: 2.0 Map \| This sprawling South Seas-style resort has grassy open areas...	$$-$$$	Shelter Island

Best Western Island Palms Hotel & Marina Be the First to Rate It Map \| This waterfront inn, with an airy lobby brightened by skylights...	$$$-$$$$	Shelter Island

Kona Kai Resort Be the First to Rate It Map \| This 11-acre property blends Mexican and Mediterranean styles...	$$$-$$$$	Shelter Island

Read the current issue
For more travel ideas, tips, and deals, sign up for the Fodor's newsletter here. Browse previous issues.